PESQUISA NA GRADUAÇÃO. CRITÉRIOS DE AVALIAÇÃO DE PROJETOS DOS ALUNOS: A QUALIDADE CIENTÍFICA HOLÍSTICA

José Antonio Bonilla Castillo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5329/RECADM.20050401007

Abstract

The article involves na evaluation proposal for Scientific Research Works (SRW) derived from Undergrad courses, which can be extended to researches executed  by Teachers, to Master’s degree dissertations and also to Doctoral Theses. Basically, the nature of the scientific method is discussed. Adittional ethical-social objectives – seen as inherent and indispensable to the research are incorporated. The interaction of both elements leads to a new concept : “holistic scientific quality “, on which the structure of the criteria of evaluation of the researches is based, in a total de 24 ( 11 scientific or methodological aspects ; 08 ethical-social and 05 complementary aspects). Specific weights are suggested for each criterion and through na example it is shown to classify each research in a scale composed by six levels ( excellent, very good, good, enough, insufficient and unacceptable).


Keywords

Ethical dimension ; holistic ; scientific quality


Compartilhe


References


BONILLA, J.A.. Relatório preliminar sobre os fundamentos do método científico, suas

limitações atuais e uma proposta para seu enriquecimento. Belo Horizonte, EPAMIG, Série

Documentos 18. 1994.

BRIEGER, F.G. Sobre a metodologia da ciência moderna experimental. Anais ESALQ 9:295-

, 1952.

BUNGE M. La investigación Científica, su estrategia y su filosofía. Barcelona, Abril, 1972.

CASTOR, B.V.J. Tecnologia apropriada: uma proposta de critérios de avaliação e sua aplicação.

Revista Administração, 18(2): 40-7. Abril/Junho, 1983.

GILLESPIE, E. The edge of objectivity: on essay in the history of scientifics ideas. Princeton,

Princeton University Press, 1981.

SCHWARTZMANN, S. Funções e metodologias de avaliação do ensino superior. Dois pontos.

:7-12, set. 1987.

SEILER, R.E. Improving the effectiness of research und development. Nova Iorque, McGrawHill.

SERVAN & SCREIBNER. O desafio mundial. Rio de Janeiro, Nova Fronteira. 1980.




Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.